4 Cases Where Juries Got It All Wrong

4 Cases Juries Got it All Wrong
By Ben Hartwig
27 February, 2019

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and juries, and the trial court system is typically efficient in giving defendants a fair shake at proving their innocence. Unfortunately, there are sometimes biases within juries, false testimonies and bad science that can lead to misinformation making it to the deliberation room and effectively convicting innocent men and women. Here’s a list of four of them:

  1. Timothy Bridges

Timothy was charged with rape and burglary in 1989 and served 25 years after a jury convicted him of the crimes. He was exonerated in 2016 after it was shown that a hair analyst provided erroneous testimony that linked him to two hairs found at the crime scene. Bridges were released in 2015 after his convictions were vacated by prosecutors.

It was discovered by Bridges’ legal team that police had failed to turn over evidence before trial, and threatened and paid informants that provided information leading to the conviction. DNA testing also excluded Bridges after his conviction.

In 1989, an elderly woman was assaulted and died 13 months later without providing a reliable description of her attacker. She denied having been raped, but doctors noted she had bruising consistent with rape upon examination. After several months, three informants said that Bridges had confessed to them, bringing a suspect to light.

A hair analyst testified there was a strong possibility that a hair found at the crime scene belonged to Bridges. Additionally, a bloody palm print found at the scene that did not match Bridges apparently didn’t hold much water for the jury to consider.

  1. William Barnhouse

William became the 350th person to be exonerated through DNA testing in May of 2017. He served 25 years for a sexual assault he didn’t commit, and the jury sentenced him to 80 years. In 1992, a woman was raped behind a building in Indiana and Barnhouse was remanded by police because he fit the description she gave of her attacker and he was in the area. He was 35 years old at the time.

Police took him back to the scene and the victim identified him as her attacker. A blood analyst testified at trial that Barnhouse couldn’t be eliminated as the source of evidence found in the rape kit. He also said that Barnhouse matched a hair that was found. Since then, this fact has been proven as a gross overstatement.

Barnhouse suffered from mental illness his entire life. The jury found him guilty but mentally ill of rape and criminal deviant conduct.

The FBI later determined the statement about Barnhouse being a “match” for the hair evidence was scientifically invalid. DNA testing of the vaginal swabs from the rape kit was conducted in 2016, which excluded Barnhouse as a suspect. He was released from prison on March 8, 2017, and the charges were dismissed just two days later.

  1. Andre Hatchett

Hatchett served a 25-year sentence for a second-degree murder conviction that brought a sentence of 25 years to life. He was wrongly convicted mostly due to unreliable testimony, inadequate defense and exculpatory evidence that was not disclosed to the defense. His conviction was reversed in 2016 after serving 25 years.

The murder victim, Neda Mae Carter, was found beaten to death on February 18, 1991, in Bedford-Stuyvesant. Hatchett had been with her earlier in the evening but cooperated with police. He has special needs and was in a cast with crutches at the time.

A witness surfaced who was arrested for a burglary, and told police he witnessed a man in the park with Carter the night of the murder. He identified Hatchett in a lineup, but the DA did not disclose information to defense attorneys that the witness identified a different man when speaking with the police.

  1. Michael Morton

Morton served 24 years in prison for the murder of his own wife before being exonerated by DNA evidence in 2011. His wife was murdered in their bed in 1986, beaten to death with a wooden weapon. Semen was also found at the scene.

Days later, a bloody bandana was discovered about 100 yards from the Morton home. Their 3-year-old son was home when the murder occurred, and the boy told his grandmother that it was not his father who murdered his mother.

Prosecutors presented no physical evidence against Morton or witnesses, but simply hypothesized that he killed his wife because she refused to be intimate with him on his birthday. He was convicted in 1987.

DNA testing was ordered in 2005 and 2011, and evidence from an unknown male was found on items from the scene. It was later matched to a man who was also connected to two other similar murders in the area.

Dash Cam

Cop Cam: How Does Police Dash Cam work?

We live in the age of video, and law enforcement has not escaped this trap.…
09 April, 2020 Law Enforcement
gun background check

What Does Gun Background Check Consist Of?

When someone purchases a gun through a licensed gun dealer, a background check is required…
06 April, 2020 Law Enforcement
car accident

Recovering After Your First Car Accident

Car accidents are never good and can sometimes be very serious or life-threatening. If this…
26 March, 2020 Safety
private investigator

Complete Guide to Hiring a Private Investigator

Whether you need to find a missing person or find out if your spouse is…
24 March, 2020 Privacy
fake news

How to Detect “Fake News” Stories: Complete Guide to Fact-Checking

The last few years have brought many changes to the world, and one of the…
20 March, 2020 Cyber Security
Know your neighbors

Who Are My Neighbors?

Whether you live in the city or suburbs, in a heavily populated area or a…
10 March, 2020 Safety
NFL Players

NFL Players and their Criminal Histories

In 2019, an average of 16.5 million people watched NFL football games. Sundays during football…
06 March, 2020 Crime
tax rates

The 10 Best Cities With the Lowest Tax Rates

There are plenty of reasons why relocating to a new city makes a whole lot…
26 February, 2020 Uncategorized
immigrants

Best Cities in America to Immigrate To

America is a nation built by immigrants. As the immigration debate rages on, there is…
19 February, 2020 Uncategorized
texting while driving

Who’s More Likely to Text and Drive – Teenagers or Their Parents?

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
27 June, 2019 Safety
background checks details

Does Infotracer Notify the Person You Ran a Background Check On?

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
10 December, 2018 Safety
best apps for cheating spouse

7 Apps to Use for Cheating Spouses

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
01 February, 2019 Dating & Relationships

Online E-Card Scam: When Good Wishes Deliver Troubles

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
11 October, 2018 Cyber Security

10 States with “No Candy” Laws for Halloween

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
06 October, 2018 Law Enforcement

What are the 5 Biggest Online Scams?

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
13 August, 2018 Cyber Security

Best and Worst States for DMV

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
15 May, 2019 Safety

5 Things You Should Know Before Exploring the “Dark Web”

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
27 August, 2018 Cyber Security

Privacy Controls: Part 2: Control your Personal Reputation Online on Google

The nation’s legal system is largely built on checks and balances between judges, courts, and…
04 September, 2018 Privacy